Back to the 2023 paper

Module 3: Performance Management and Industrial Relations

20237m

Discuss the functions of Trade Unions. What is the impact of globalization on Trade Unions?

Worked SolutionAI Assisted

Functions of Trade Unions & Impact of Globalization (7M)

Definition: Trade Union - voluntary organization of workers formed to protect and promote their common interests through collective action (Trade Unions Act 1926).

Functions of Trade Unions (Militant, Fraternal, Social):

1. Economic / Militant Function (Core):

  • Collective bargaining for wages, bonus, allowances, job security.
  • Protect against layoffs, victimization.
  • Example: Bank unions bargaining for 12th bipartite settlement 2024.

2. Welfare / Fraternal Function:

  • Education, training, cultural programs, housing cooperatives, legal aid, recreational facilities for members & families.

3. Protective Function:

  • Representation in grievances, disciplinary proceedings, Industrial Disputes.

4. Social & Political Function:

  • Workers' education, political lobbying, participation in policy (INTUC-Congress link), social reforms.

5. Developmental / Cooperative Function (Modern):

  • Help in increasing productivity, discipline, quality circles, gain sharing - post-1991.

Impact of Globalization on Trade Unions:

Negative / Challenges:

  1. Decline in Membership & Density: Privatization, downsizing, contract labour, informal sector growth reduced unionized workforce from 10% to 6%. MNCs discourage unions (Maruti initially non-union).
  2. Bargaining Power Erosion: Global competition pressures cost-cutting, flexible labour laws, threat of relocation ("race to bottom"), makes unions accept concessions.
  3. Shift from Central to Enterprise Bargaining: Industry-wide bargaining weakened; plant-level, productivity-linked deals.
  4. New Forms of Employment: Gig economy (Swiggy), IT sector with individual contracts, where traditional unionism doesn't reach.
  5. Technology & Automation: Reduces manual workforce, reduces union base.

Positive / Opportunities:

  1. Transnational Solidarity: Global Union Federations (ITUC), ILO decent work agenda give platform.
  2. New Agenda Issues: Unions now raise issues beyond wages - work-life, stress, gender equality, environmental, CSR, skill upgrading for global competition.
  3. Professionalization: Need for more skilled, educated union leadership to negotiate with MNC HR, understand finance, productivity.
  4. Alliance with Management: From adversarial to partnership - e.g., Tata Steel union cooperates for productivity for global competitiveness.

Conclusion: Globalization weakened traditional militant unionism but forced unions to evolve from wage bargaining to strategic partnership focusing on employability, social security, and competitiveness. Future unions must organize informal/gig workers, upgrade skills, and embrace collaborative IR to remain relevant.

Similar questions

Budget AppAndroid App

Pocketly on Android

Log daily food, travel, and hostel expenses instantly. Set monthly spending limits and see where your money goes without complex spreadsheets.